Reducing Hesitation in Resuscitation: Educational Effects of a Female-Appearing Simulator in Basic Life Support Training

Women are less likely than men to receive timely defibrillation during out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. We investigated whether using a simulator that is visually modified to resemble a female affects learners’ attitudes, knowledge, and performance in basic life support (BLS) training. In a BLS simulation training, first-year medical students (n=220) used a standard gender-neutral simulator (control group) or a modified simulator with a female-like appearance (intervention group). Pre- and post-training questionnaires concerning attitudes and knowledge plus a post-training skills evaluation assessed the students’ training outcomes. The intervention group initiated chest compressions significantly faster than the control group (33.1 vs. 39.8 sec, p<0.01) and achieved a significantly higher rate of correct AED pad placement (64.2% vs. 38.5%, p<0.01). While performing the resuscitation on the female-appearing manikin, the intervention group showed significantly greater increases in self-efficacy (p<0.01) and larger decreases in discomfort about removing the patient’s clothes (p<0.01). They were also significantly more likely to recognize that chest compressions can be performed (p=0.016) and AED pads can be applied (p=0.015) without removing the patient’s underwear. Using a female-appearing simulator in BLS training was thus associated with faster chest compression initiation, more accurate AED pad placement, and improved gender-sensitive attitudes and knowledge.