This study examines why organizations facing similar institutional complexity pursue different response pathways.
Drawing on institutional complexity and performance feedback theory, we argued that competing institutional demands increase the likelihood of symbolic adoption and that organizational performance shapes the salience of such demands, thereby influencing the likelihood of symbolic adoption.
Using data on Japanese corporate governance reforms, we found that institutional complexity alone does not uniformly lead to symbolic adoption. Rather, symbolic adoption is more likely to occur when organizational performance deteriorates.
These findings advance understanding of response heterogeneity under institutional complexity and extend performance feedback theory to institutional contexts.